“Our Prophet (peace be upon him) is not known to have murdered anyone, nor given any order to kill.”
“Kill any Jew that falls into your power!”
This was the order Muhammad issued following his people’s murder of another Jew named Ka’b al-Ashraf. From the nighttime assassination of Asma bint Marwan (a poet and mother of five) to the Christians killed at Tabuk, this is but one of many examples from the Sira that refute the silly idea that the prophet of Islam never approved of murder.
The successful and gory assassination of al-Ashraf convinced Muhammad that the time was right to assert his dominance in Medina. He wanted to instill terror into the hearts of the local Jewish population, many of whom were having second thoughts about allowing the Muslim immigrants into their community. Muhammad had already begun killing and evicting them only eighteen months after arriving.
The intimidation campaign was particularly targeted at the the last two surviving Jewish tribes (the Nadir and Qurayza). Gleeful over the successful assassination of the Nadir leader, al-Ashraf, the prophet of Islam immediately exhorted his men to a random murder spree that would further narrow down any opposition via terror and conversion.
Following Muhammad’s mandate to kill “any Jew that falls into your power,” a Muslim follower stabbed his Jewish business partner to death. The Muslim’s brother was initially horrified by the crime, since they were not only on friendly terms with the victim, but the merchant was integral to their own livelihood:
The unbelieving brother is quite impressed with Muhammad’s ability to break the social contract and influence the killing even of one’s own family. As such, he accepts the “Religion of Peace” on the spot (assuming his conversion was not out of self-preservation).
Another example of Muhammad clearly approving of murder occurred following a botched attempt to assassinate a rival in Mecca. Muhammad’s hand-picked assassins were discovered before they could carry out their mission and had to hide in a cave. An innocent man grazing his horse soon came their way:
After this, the killers later found themselves in another cave, into which a one-eyed shepherd haplessly entered while taking a break:
Amazingly, the murder spree was not yet finished. The Muslims killed a third Meccan on the way back and took another prisoner. Muhammad was told about the various murders, including that of the sleeping shepherd whose only “crime” was to say that he would never be Muslim. His reaction:
Even the devout Muslim historians could not help but note these and other examples of Muhammad ordering or approving the killing of non-Muslims who were not guilty of capital crimes. Since murder is defined in Islam as a person killing another member of their own class (see the Law of Equality, Quran 2:178), becoming a Muslim was the only way to ensure that one wasn’t murdered by Muhammad’s men at the time. Hence the religion’s early success.